Sunday, January 26, 2014

Said is ALIVE.







"Isabelle!" Jack proclaimed loudly. 

"What do you want, Jack?" Isabelle cried hysterically. "Haven't you done enough?" 

"Please," he pleaded desperately, "don't leave." 

"I can't stay," she whispered through a wave of tears. 

"But--" he began urgently. 

"No," she interrupted quickly, "It's too late." 

He watched her go...sadly. 

                    ***

Hey, look! I wrote some awesome dialogue! Wanna know why it's so awesome? Because I didn't use the word "said" ONCE. That must mean I tried super hard and that it sounds professional and stuff, right? WRONG, I say!

I can't tell you how many writers, teachers, and readers have made the claim that, "said is dead." This frustrates me to no end because it is just ridiculously incorrect and, frankly, ignorant. This saying is what has given some of my students the desire to tag EVERY line of dialogue with a different descriptor along with an unnecessary adverb like the example I gave above. The dialogue tags are so wordy in themselves that the dialogue feels too spaced out and drags significantly. Take a look at it without ALL of those tags.



"Isabelle!"  

"What do you want, Jack?" Isabelle said. "Haven't you done enough?" 

"Please...don't leave." 

"I can't stay," she whispered. 

"But--" 

"No," she said. "It's too late." 

He watched her go, knowing she was right. 


Now, I'll admit, this isn't my best piece of dialogue, but you get my point. Dialogue is meant to show you what the characters are saying in a particular scene and, if it is well written, you should rarely need to explain how they are saying it.

I am currently an English teacher and I can't tell you how many of my students tell me that their past teachers have told them to never use the word "said." As I've stated in a previous blog, never say never. (Pardon the Bieber quote)

Some authors, like Stephen King, actually advocate using the word "said" unless absolutely necessary. King also says that unneeded dialogue tags like "sadly" and "urgently" should all be trashed.

“The road to hell is paved with adverbs.” 
― Stephen King, On Writing

I do use the occasional adverb, as does Stephen King, but I think the idea here is that less is best. If I find myself using a dialogue tag that is easily explainable through the character's words, I will just delete it.

So, what I am getting at here is: said is not dead. So, English teachers, please stop teaching your students this. -_-